Difference between revisions of "3D printed LED Ringflash"
m (Updated mount print results) |
(added results and flower picture) |
||
| (4 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
==Problem Statement == | ==Problem Statement == | ||
| − | Macro subjects are hard to capture with even lighting. It is easy to shadow the subject due to the close proximity of the lens. The solution is to use a ringflash. They are expensive and I thought it would be fun to design one myself. I wanted to create two different units, one with LED lighting and one with actual flash tubes. I don't want to use digital control. This is both a personal challenge and a robustness requirement. If it "Just Works" (TM) I'll be more likely to use it than if it needs software written and tweaked and uploaded and interfaced with blah. I also want it to be very small so that it can be mounted on the hotshoe. I want something that will have power saving measures if I want to go traveling with it. | + | Macro subjects are hard to capture with even lighting. It is easy to shadow the subject due to the close proximity of the lens. The solution is to use a ringflash. They are expensive and I thought it would be fun to design one myself. I wanted to create two different units, one with LED lighting and one with [[3D_Printed_Strobe_Ringlight|actual flash tubes]]. I don't want to use digital control. This is both a personal challenge and a robustness requirement. If it "Just Works" (TM) I'll be more likely to use it than if it needs software written and tweaked and uploaded and interfaced with blah. I also want it to be very small so that it can be mounted on the hotshoe. I want something that will have power saving measures if I want to go traveling with it. |
==System Overview == | ==System Overview == | ||
The system consists of a controller PCB, a 3D printed mount for the controller PCB, a power source, a 3D printed structure to mount the lights on, and the lights themselves. | The system consists of a controller PCB, a 3D printed mount for the controller PCB, a power source, a 3D printed structure to mount the lights on, and the lights themselves. | ||
| − | [[Image:RingflashTesting.jpg| | + | [[Image:RingflashTesting.jpg|left|400px]][[Image:Ringflash_Cree_SMD_OnCam.jpg|none|400px]] |
== Controller == | == Controller == | ||
| Line 38: | Line 38: | ||
=== LEDs === | === LEDs === | ||
At first I chose NTE30071 LEDs. This seemed like a great solution because they're bright, they run at 25mA, and they have built in 40 degree lenses, so at least for closeup work they should be bright. However, in practice it was found that the light was not even (it was shaped like a halo), the LEDs were not bright enough, and the color temperature varied significantly between LEDs. | At first I chose NTE30071 LEDs. This seemed like a great solution because they're bright, they run at 25mA, and they have built in 40 degree lenses, so at least for closeup work they should be bright. However, in practice it was found that the light was not even (it was shaped like a halo), the LEDs were not bright enough, and the color temperature varied significantly between LEDs. | ||
| − | [[Image:RingflashV1.1_top2.JPG|left|400px|thumb|The NTE30071 LEDs are kinda cool looking...]]<br clear="both"> | + | [[Image:RingflashV1.1_top2.JPG|left|400px|thumb|The NTE30071 LEDs are kinda cool looking...]] |
| + | [[Image:Ringflash_Cree_SMD_Side.jpg|none|400px|thumb]]<br clear="both"> | ||
| − | For V2 I have ordered some Cree CLA1B-WKW series LEDs which are much brighter (10 lumins instead of 3 at 30mA), have even 120 degree light, and can be run at up to 80mA. | + | |
| + | For V2 I have ordered some Cree CLA1B-WKW series LEDs which are much brighter (10 lumins instead of 3 at 30mA), have even 120 degree light, and can be run at up to 80mA. The onboard regulator can only output 500mA at 5V (50mA per LED), so changes to the board would be required to run them at full brightness or to push over 6.5V required to run two in series for twice the light output per current (This modification was made, but requires about 8.2V to drive full 800mA current). | ||
= Structure = | = Structure = | ||
== Ring == | == Ring == | ||
| − | The ring structure was designed to be very basic, it is just a cone that aims the LEDs towards the closest focus spot on my 90mm tamron macro lens. | + | The ring structure was designed to be very basic, it is just a cone that aims the LEDs towards the closest focus spot on my 90mm tamron macro lens. Printing was done in two parts to avoid using support material. |
| − | [[Image:Ringflash_1.1_sideview.png| | + | [[Image:Ringflash_1.1_sideview.png|left|400px]][[Image:Ringflash_1.1_bottom_view.png|none|400px]] |
| − | [[Image:RingflashV1.1_bot.JPG| | + | [[Image:RingflashV1.1_bot.JPG|left|400px]][[Image:RingflashLEDWiring.jpg|none|400px]] |
| + | |||
| + | [[Image:Ringflash_Cree_SMD_Mount_Back.jpg|left|400px]][[Image:Ringflash Cree SMD Mount Front.jpg|none|225px]] | ||
| + | <br clear="both"> | ||
== Mount == | == Mount == | ||
The hotshoe mount has been designed and printed out of black PLA using an Ultimaker running Cura set to 0.1mm layer height, 15% fill, linear support structures under the overhang. The print fits the hotshoe right off the bed, but required some slight sanding to fit the PCB which was slightly oversized from the fab. Locktite flexible plastic adhesive was used to secure the PCB to the mount. The batteries are currently not optimized. Once I find a 2-cell pack with a convenient form factor the mount can be resigned to include a top cover for environmental protection. | The hotshoe mount has been designed and printed out of black PLA using an Ultimaker running Cura set to 0.1mm layer height, 15% fill, linear support structures under the overhang. The print fits the hotshoe right off the bed, but required some slight sanding to fit the PCB which was slightly oversized from the fab. Locktite flexible plastic adhesive was used to secure the PCB to the mount. The batteries are currently not optimized. Once I find a 2-cell pack with a convenient form factor the mount can be resigned to include a top cover for environmental protection. | ||
| − | [[Image:RingflashHotshoeMount.png|left| | + | [[Image:RingflashHotshoeMount.png|left|400px]][[Image:RingflashHotshoePCBholderAssembled.jpg|none|400px]] |
| + | |||
| + | == Results == | ||
| + | <flickr>13678734435|left</flickr><br clear="both"> | ||
| + | The light is not bright enough, even with the cree LEDs doubled up per channel. Also, the triggering/interface leaves something to be desired and may need tweaking. I think that I might need to either move to a strobe version or add some sort of lenses to focus the lights onto the subject. However, the large number of lights make for very very even lighting as shown in the photo. | ||
Latest revision as of 16:17, 8 April 2014
Problem Statement
Macro subjects are hard to capture with even lighting. It is easy to shadow the subject due to the close proximity of the lens. The solution is to use a ringflash. They are expensive and I thought it would be fun to design one myself. I wanted to create two different units, one with LED lighting and one with actual flash tubes. I don't want to use digital control. This is both a personal challenge and a robustness requirement. If it "Just Works" (TM) I'll be more likely to use it than if it needs software written and tweaked and uploaded and interfaced with blah. I also want it to be very small so that it can be mounted on the hotshoe. I want something that will have power saving measures if I want to go traveling with it.
System Overview
The system consists of a controller PCB, a 3D printed mount for the controller PCB, a power source, a 3D printed structure to mount the lights on, and the lights themselves.
Controller
The controller uses a 5V 500mA REG103GA voltage regulator. I chose 10 LED channels because when I hooked up 5x NTE30071 it wasn't bright enough. More than 10 seems silly and like I should be doing something else with the space, like buck-boosting to a level where the LEDs could be in series. This means that each channel can output up to 50mA.
There are two dials, one sets the "focus" brightness which is always on, and the other sets the "flash" brightness, which is meant to be used for the actual photo.
BOM Notes
Reg to use: http://www.ti.com/product/reg103-5 (SOT223-5 package)
Op-amps to use: MCP6L71/1R/2/4 http://ww1.microchip.com/downloads/en/DeviceDoc/22145a.pdf
LEDs to use: NTE30071 http://www.radioshack.com/product/index.jsp?productId=12580024
Trimpot to use for setting reference voltage TC33X-2-103E http://www.digikey.com/product-detail/en/TC33X-2-103E/TC33X-103ECT-ND/612911
Simulation
The circuit was simulated in LTSpice and checks out.
LEDs
At first I chose NTE30071 LEDs. This seemed like a great solution because they're bright, they run at 25mA, and they have built in 40 degree lenses, so at least for closeup work they should be bright. However, in practice it was found that the light was not even (it was shaped like a halo), the LEDs were not bright enough, and the color temperature varied significantly between LEDs.
For V2 I have ordered some Cree CLA1B-WKW series LEDs which are much brighter (10 lumins instead of 3 at 30mA), have even 120 degree light, and can be run at up to 80mA. The onboard regulator can only output 500mA at 5V (50mA per LED), so changes to the board would be required to run them at full brightness or to push over 6.5V required to run two in series for twice the light output per current (This modification was made, but requires about 8.2V to drive full 800mA current).
Structure
Ring
The ring structure was designed to be very basic, it is just a cone that aims the LEDs towards the closest focus spot on my 90mm tamron macro lens. Printing was done in two parts to avoid using support material.
Mount
The hotshoe mount has been designed and printed out of black PLA using an Ultimaker running Cura set to 0.1mm layer height, 15% fill, linear support structures under the overhang. The print fits the hotshoe right off the bed, but required some slight sanding to fit the PCB which was slightly oversized from the fab. Locktite flexible plastic adhesive was used to secure the PCB to the mount. The batteries are currently not optimized. Once I find a 2-cell pack with a convenient form factor the mount can be resigned to include a top cover for environmental protection.
Results
The light is not bright enough, even with the cree LEDs doubled up per channel. Also, the triggering/interface leaves something to be desired and may need tweaking. I think that I might need to either move to a strobe version or add some sort of lenses to focus the lights onto the subject. However, the large number of lights make for very very even lighting as shown in the photo.
